FBI Ruse Violated Rights of Vegas Hotel Guest, US Judge Says
April 20, 2015
District Judge Andrew Gordon said in a bluntly worded decision.
“There is not a constitutional right to DSL,” she said.
Phua’s lawyers also disputed allegations that their client had criminal ties.
Gordon’s 22-page ruling effectively guts the criminal prosecution of a man authorities characterized as a top member of an Asian organized crime syndicate who flew to Las Vegas last summer on his private jet after having been arrested and charged with operating an illegal sports betting business in the Asian gambling hub of Macau.
“Law enforcement can’t break something in your house and pose as repair people to get inside,” Chesnoff said.
Phua’s attorneys said they were stunned to learn that investigators enlisted a Caesars contractor to shut off Internet access so agents disguised as repairmen could enter with hidden cameras.
Federal prosecutors conceded mistakes but argued that the government did nothing malicious and had not violated Phua’s constitutional rights.
Gordon called the evidence collected from Phua’s suite “fruits of an unconstitutional search,” and said it can’t be used if the government presses forward with charges that Phua operated an illegal gambling business and transmitted wagering information. Agents seized computers, cellphones and cash.
“Permitting the government to create the need for the occupant to invite a third party into his or her home would effectively allow the government to conduct warrantless searches of the vast majority of residences and hotel rooms in America,” the judge wrote.
Phua, 50, is the last remaining defendant among eight people arrested in the case, including his son Darren Wai Kit Phua, 23.. Officials with the FBI referred messages seeking comment to the U.S. attorney’s office in Las Vegas, which didn’t immediately respond.
“We hope this will bring the case to a close because the decision suppresses all the evidence that directly involves Mr. The two charges each carry a penalty of up to seven years in prison.
The decision, however, doesn’t kill the case outright.
His ruling threw out evidence collected last July from Wei Seng “Paul” Phua’s high-security luxury villa at Caesars Palace.
Prosecutor Kimberly Frayn argued that Internet service isn’t an essential service like electricity, air conditioning or water, and that people in the Caesars Palace villas weren’t compelled to invite in the agents disguised as repairmen.
The FBI violated the rights of a wealthy Malaysian businessman when agents posed as Internet repairmen to get into his Las Vegas hotel suite to search for evidence of wrongdoing during the World Cup soccer tournament last summer, a federal judge ruled Friday.
Prosecutors said some $13 million in bets had been wagered before the FBI, working with Nevada gambling regulators, raided three Caesars Palace villas where Phua, his son and several other people were staying. Charges against one defendant were dismissed.
“The government violated the defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights” against unreasonable searches and seizures, U.S. for five years. Phua,” defense attorney Thomas Goldstein said.
The defense lawyers accused the FBI of deceiving a magistrate judge who granted a search warrant by failing to disclose the tactics used to find probable cause, and leaving any reference to the ruse out of investigative reports.
“This had implications for all Americans,” defense attorney David Chesnoff said, hailing the decision as a victory for freedom.
Darren Phua was the last of six defendants to plead guilty to lesser charges, forfeit large amounts of money and return to Asia under plea deals banning them from travel to the U.S
Latest posts by Amelia Woodward (see all)
- My Top 5 Sports Betting Sites - March 26, 2017
- Stossel: My political advice for 2016? Place your bets - January 27, 2017
- GBGC – Asia Has 10 of the Worldâs Largest Casinos - January 26, 2017